Reimagining the Federal Role in Career-Connected Education and Workforce Development

By: Robert Schwartz

One thing I can confidently predict is that, with all the focus on the two “A’s” -- affordability and accountability – the next Congress is unlikely to devote much attention to the federal role in education and workforce development. The upside is that this gives time for the Harvard Project on Workforce (HPoW) and others in the research and policy community to reimagine new and better ways for the Federal government to support the integration of work and learning, ideas that could be fed into the thinking of both political parties as they begin to shape their policy platforms for the 2028 election.
One perennial question is where in the federal government is the best organizational home for programs that aim to integrate education and workforce development. The Trump Administration’s answer to this question was to move OCTAE – -the Office of Career, Technical, and Adult Education –- from the Education Department to the Labor Department. This move might seem logical and has historical precedent. In 1995 when Congress passed the School to Work Opportunity Act, the Education and Labor Departments collaborated in creating a school-to-work office that was staffed by appointees from both agencies. However, if there was a single lesson to be learned from the Biden Administration’s work in this space, it is that federal workforce programs that lead to real employment require collaboration across three agencies, not two, and that it’s Commerce that probably should be in the lead because of its close ties with business. The case for a much more demand-driven approach to workforce development is powerfully articulated in a new book by our HPoW colleague, Rachel Lipson, The New American Frontier, Job Training for the Next Technological Age.
The impetus for this book grew out of Lipson’s role as a senior advisor on workforce development for the CHIPS team at Commerce. The CHIPS and Science Act had many pieces, but its hallmark feature was its focus on bringing back semiconductor manufacturing to the U.S. by directly funding companies like Intel and the Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company (TSMC) that decided to build major new fabrication factories in states like Ohio and Arizona. A less known but for our purposes critical component of these grants was the inclusion of major funding for workforce development, the majority of which was for jobs that do not require a four-year degree.
The effect of putting workforce development funds directly in the hands of employers was to ensure that the funded training programs were designed to meet the job specifications identified by the companies and their suppliers, which meant that there were real jobs waiting for those who completed training. As Lipson notes, this approach proceeds from a diametrically different model than the one undergirding the American workforce development system. Our current workforce system begins with identifying target populations -- unemployed youth, displaced workers, etc – and then funds provider organizations to develop programs to serve these populations. While there is usually a requirement that providers consult with employers (typically, by creating an employer advisory committee), there is no requirement that there be a job waiting at the end of the training period. This approach, unfortunately, is often characterized as “train and pray.”
Across seven regions, from battery plants in Michigan to data centers in Virginia to nuclear reactors in Idaho, in The New American Frontier (TNAF) Lipson tells the story of what happens when leading edge technologies land in communities that then have to train people for new and changing jobs, many of which don’t require a four-year degree. These seven case studies, based on on-the-ground observation and interviews with 120 participants, provide an extraordinarily detailed look at the challenges industry and government and community college leaders in these jurisdictions face in rapidly creating and scaling training programs to meet the skill requirements of these frontier industries.
Lipson’s conclusions from her experience with the CHIPS program and from these fascinating case studies suggest a radical rethinking about the federal role in workforce development. Her first and most important recommendation is that we think of workforce development not as an anti-poverty program but as an essential component of regional and national economic competitiveness. We should prioritize industries that are key to competitiveness, not just the kind of frontier technology industries profiled in TNAF, but industries like child care and elder care that are essential to the full-time participation in the workforce of women and other family caregivers. As noted above, she argues that program planning should begin on the demand side by identifying real jobs in these targeted industries. As she says, “If programs don’t have real jobs and careers on the other side of their training, we are ultimately failing the people who go through these programs.”
Another key lesson from Lipson’s case studies is the importance of investing in regional intermediaries, organizations that can play the critical convening, coordinating, and managing roles essential to bringing together the key public and private partners in a region and helping them build the collaborative, learning culture required to move from initial planning and piloting to full-scale implementation.
The cross-agency, public/private partnership approach at the regional level needs to be mirrored in Washington. As we rethink the federal role, we need to reinvent some new structures to support career-connected education and workforce development that cross agency borders. Interagency task forces are fine for improving communication, but they generally are disconnected from major funding streams. In Massachusetts spanning two gubernatorial Administrations we’ve had a Workforce Skills Cabinet, co-led by deputy or assistant secretaries of Education, Labor and Workforce Development, and Economic Development, responsible for allocating capital grants to the Commonwealth’s vocational-technical high schools and community colleges as well as operational funds for late afternoon and evening skills training programs at the voc schools. Perhaps a similar structure could be created at the federal level, co-led by assistant secretaries from Commerce, Labor, and Education, with responsibility for managing a competitive grants program for industry-led regional partnerships analogous to the Biden-era $1 billion Build Back Better program administered by Commerce’s Economic Development Agency (EDA).
As it happens, as I was drafting this blog I read in Paul Fain’s newsletter about a new Industry-Led Talent Initiative, designed to “to strengthen the role employers play in the public systems that shape talent – so that career-focused education, training, and workforce systems produce the skills employers actually need, and learners reach the good jobs those systems were built to deliver.” This suggests that there are allies in the employer and workforce development community ready to join in the rethinking Lipson is calling for.
